11/27/2006: Here is the list of candidates for induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Here are my picks:
(1) Bert Blyleven. He won plenty of games, and came up big when it counted: the 1979 World Series (with the Pittsburgh Pirates) and the 1987 World Series (for the Minnesota Twins). Surely a place that accommodates Don Sutton has a place for Blyleven.
(2) Steve Garvey. He–and Jim Rice–are the top stars from the 1970s and 1980s who are not yet in the Hall. While Garvey’s antics off the field are regrettable, he was a consistent 200-hit/.300 average player year-in and year-out for the Los Angeles Dodgers. He didn’t miss many games. He even delivered a World Series for LA.
(3) Goose Gossage. He was THE dominant closer of his time, and helped usher in the era of the dominant closer. His fastball was devastating, and–when the Yankees needed him–he delivered big-time.
(4) Tony Gwynn. He picked up where Rod Carew left off, and then some. 8 batting titles. .338 career batting average. 3,141 hits. Only 434 career strikeouts in 9,288 at-bats. Yup…he’s in.
(5) Jack Morris. Even though his ERA is high for a would-be Cooperstown resident, Morris was one of the finest clutch pitchers in baseball history, winning two World Series championships. He was also the winningest pitcher in the 1980s.
(6) Jim Rice. For nearly 15 years, he was one of the most-feared hitters in baseball. While he could not deliver a World Series, that had less to do with him and more to do with the curse of the Bambino, as Rice–with teammates Fred Lynn and Hall-of-Famers Carl Yazstrzemski and Carlton Fisk–played for the cursed Boston Red Sox. He was a great hitter, not to mention a perennial all-star. Baseball writers–out of spite–have long ostracized Rice on account of his shoddy treatment of the news media. Quite frankly, I find that unfair. He was one of the dominant players of his era, and is very deserving of a place in Cooperstown.
(7) Cal Ripken, Jr. Aside from breaking Lou Gehrig’s record for consecutive games, Ripken was the finest shorstop of his era.
(8) Lee Smith. He deserves to be in. 478 saves, a 3.03 ERA, 1,251 strikeouts in 1,289 innings. 7-time all-star.
Here are those–of note–whom I consider undeserving this year:
(1) Mark McGwire. Without steroids, Mac would not have HOF-caliber stats. That, however, is not true regarding Barry Bonds, who had HOF numbers before he discovered BALCO. Bonds would get my vote, but not Mac.
(2) Albert Belle. He put up Jim Rice-caliber numbers, but that was during the Steroid Era. Rice, on the other hand, led the AL in games, at-bats, runs scored, hits, homers, RBIs, slugging percentage, total bases, extra-base hits, multi-hit games, and outfield assists during a ten-year 1975-1984 stretch.
(3) Tommy John. A fine player, but not HOF caliber.
(4) Dave Parker. He’s on the bubble. As a fan of the 1979 Pittsburgh Pirates and owner of several Parker baseball cards, I’d love to see him voted in. He had solid stats, was a complete player, and has two World Series rings, but I’m not convinced that his stats are completely HOF-caliber. His cocaine usage also weighs against him.
(5) Orel Hershiser. A fine pitcher who will eventually get in. He was a stellar pitcher who came back from rotator cuff surgery to have a long, productive career. His stats are on the bubble, but with over 200 wins and an ERA under 3.50, he will get voted in by the veterans committee one day.
(6) Don Mattingly. Like Orel Hershiser, he’ll make it in eventually. In fact, the case for Mattingly is better than the case for Hershiser. His stats are good enough, and–even in his twilight–he put up good batting averages in spite of back problems. He finished his career batting .307 with more than 400 doubles, 200 homers, and 1,000 RBIs. He was also an outstanding fielder.
(6) Dale Murphy. A fine player who was great for the game, but with a career batting average of only .265–while having well under 500 homers–he’s not HOF material.
(7) Wally Joyner. Stats are not even in the ballpark for HOF consideration, not even for a first-baseman.
(8) Bret Saberhagen. Excellent pitcher, noted for his great performance in the 1985 World Series. But his overall stats are not HOF-caliber. While his ERA is good enough, having less than 200 wins doesn’t qualify.
(9) Andre Dawson. He’ll get in, but not this year.
The ones I want to see in the Hall, but will never get in:
(1) Thurman Munson, who was killed in a plane crash short of his tenth full season.
(2) Pete Rose. While his gambling activities are shameful, I believe his on-field performance merits a place in Cooperstown. He should also be permitted to attend all-star events and “Old Timer” games. On the other hand, he should not be allowed to manage, coach, or own a Major League Baseball team
Another Sad Chapter in the Church
11/29/2007: This qualified as my first article in the WTF category.
55-year-old Howard Douglas Porter, former pastor of Hickman Community Church, apparently killed 85-year-old Frank Craig for his 4+million dollar trust fund.